Production/consumption plays an important role in
female/girl community. In the intro, “Mary” describes the importance of production/consumption
most succinctly when she describes “piecing” as a means of ordering or controlling
a life that is mostly beyond one’s control. “The material is what is passed on
to you or all you can afford to buy...But the way you put them together is your
business” (20). Control, a feeling of being in control or having control over
an aspect of yourself, is a way that many clothing lines, make-up, and other
girl product lines gets women in the mood to buy. As one of the previous articles
discussed, it isn’t the product but the promise that the product offers that is
most appealing. In “piecing” for quilts, Mary describes the sense of control
born of material things. However, materiality also connotes comfort in
female/girl communities as the stories from the “youth” portion of the pdf’s
illustrate. The quilts, unlike a set of clothes or dresses or shoes, connect
meaning with the material in a way that the material alone (the clothes and
dresses, jewelry, etc) cannot. I think this speaks directly to the ordering Mary
talks about in the intro, but as the piecing triggers memories, so too do the
pieces, organized into quilt, create linear narratives of memory. Be it measles,
or pride, the quilts represented in the readings position the production of
quilts as something beyond the original products from which they are taken. The
generations that follow the quilters and the quilts retain pride beyond the
material. It’s legacy wrapped up in female/girl community that makes the quilt
less of a product and more an experience, or tradition. This speaks to the
inherent treasure of such practices, that they can’t be bought, easily had, and
the emotions and memories associated with them are priceless.
I really like your assertion of "legacy" and girl "community" making "quilts less of a product and more of an experience". Although, I'm not entirely convinced that legacy and tradition are the only ways with which products take on the realm of experience. I think there is a discursive production at work even in the work of creating legacy and loving connection. The pride in creating a quilt can be both a material pride (or a pride in the aesthetic nature of a self-produced product) and also a pride of tradition, love, legacy, and connection. I'm not convinced that the quilt making we saw in the articles leans further to one side more so than the other. Which would, perhaps create a somewhat dichotomized idea of product and experience.
ReplyDelete